I started out on LibraryThing. It was okay. I recently read that LibraryThing is more for "librarian/metadata types". Maybe that's why I decided that I like GoodReads and Shelfari better. What I would actually wish for is to be able to take features from all three and combine them into the perfect online forum for my library.
GoodReads Pros
- They have nice widgets.
- You can make as many shelves as you would like, i.e., for classics, fiction, biographies, etc.
- The shelves are easy to customize
GoodReads Cons
- While you have a "to read" shelf, if you were to make a "wish list" shelf, those books would be added into your library count.
- I would like to be able to make a wish list of books that I want without them being counted as books I already own. My "to read" shelf only consists of books I currently own.
Shelfari Pros
- I like that you can leave other uses quick notes.
- You can make notes about your books, i.e., their condition, when you read them, etc., that other users can't see.
- They have a "Wish List" shelf that does exactly what I want it to do (see above).
- When you click on a book, you can see what other people thought of it, even if they just gave it a star rating. You can also see what reading groups have added that particular book to their group.
- I like the home page the best out of all three sites.
Shelfari Cons
- You can't make customized shelves. At least I haven't yet figured out how if you can.
- I wish that the "date read" were visible to other users.
See my dilemma? Shelfari currently has my most complete library. If I can't decide, I'll just use them both, lol
P.S.
I can't believe that it's Dec 3 and it's 70 degrees outside. Vermont is getting 6-12 inches of snow, hehehe.
I have tried all three myself. I gave up on GoodReads. It wasn't at all what I was looking for. I just joined Shelfari because I have a few friends who prefer that site, but it lacks so much of what I would like to do with a program like that. I've been with LibraryThing for a year now and I still love it. I prefer it over the rest. It may not be as pretty a site, but I can do so much more with it--make lists, easy mass tagging, and a few other features which the other two fell way short on.
ReplyDeleteI'm not 100% happy with any of them. I figure that I didn't give LibraryThing enough of a chance since that seems to be the preferred site over the other two.
ReplyDeleteI think I like Shelfari the best but I eventually abandoned it and haven't updated in forever. I've tried GoodReads too but didn't care for it. I haven't tried Library Thing.
ReplyDeletePam~It can be hard to keep them updated if you read a lot.
ReplyDelete